Doctor Adil Baguirov Options



It talks about Iranians (tats) with beards (Oghuz Turks at that time ended up generally mongloid like Turkomens) carrying out Azzan even though Iranians were not Islamified nevertheless 1300 yrs in the past. It talks about the land of Rum, although At the moment it was not even in the arms of Muslims! Dede Korkut (the lifestyle of Oghuz Turks) is completely through the Oghuz culture. [sixteen]. In truth to point out that's not as previous as Mr. Baguirov along with other ultra-nationalists assert, the word "istanbul" is located in this e book. And I quote[17]: The merchants established out on their own extended journey and traveled steadily For a lot of days and nights. They arrived ultimately to the city of

Эту же мысль подчеркивает Е.Э.Бертельс: «все авторы охарактеризованной группы, начиная с Катрана, обнаруживают известную общность стиля.

Exactly what is even the usage of proclaiming him for a Turk, when he was not a person and even if there was a 0% chance he was, he was assimilated entirely and didn't go away even a person line of Turkish literature and did not lead for their heritage.

Almost all Students acknowledge that outstanding advanced poetry is usually a evidence of high tradition. As well as the medium of the higher lifestyle was without a doubt the Persian language.

The person AdilBaguirov is creating precisely the same mistake. The Seljuks simply conquered the land However they definitely did not hold the guy electric power nor the populace to get inhabited all of it. Infact, the Turkification of Azeri's began someday after the invasion from the seljuks, when a lot of them in fact settled in exactly what is right now azerbaijan and turkey. Azeri's Ended up iranic at some time from the seljuks and in many cases until ottoman moments the most important language with the area was a western Iranian language.

By this “logic”, we cannot use Vahid Dasgirdi, who wrote in 1930s, and Said Nefisi, wrote in fifties, just to call several Students whom Mr. Doostzadeh has long been mentioning extensively (and which he obviously regrets now), as all of them wrote much more than 50 many years ago. Let alone the resurrected from naphthalene specific M.Kapustin who wrote his paid-for-by-Armenian-propaganda write-up in 1988 (in case Mr. Doostzadeh didn’t realize nevertheless, USSR ceased to exist in 1991). Of course, it absolutely was a paid out-for propaganda article as neither was Kapustin a scholar, nor a Nizami professional, nor was it coincidence that a simultaneous and similar article by an Armenian writer was also posted in a Soviet Armenian newspaper as I currently exposed. Incidentally, Mr. Doostzadeh is repeating the baseless claim that Kapustin is a “scholar” of “Iranian research” – Most likely Mr.

On no account I'm likely to just accept that he was 50 % Oghuz Turkic, once the overpowering proof implies usually and Western Students have not talked about this both and neither did any historians and biographers in the aged ages that wrote about Nizami.

In addition to Mr. Baguirov wrote: Also, IV) Persian/Farsi, is similar to almost every other language – no a lot more, no less, Consequently Enable’s not about-idealize or in any other case idolize it. A language as usually means of communications Probably. But as you'll official statement be able to see by this post, Persian is just not another language and also a language calls for society and record and civilization to create masterpieces like Nizami Ganjavi.

Let's not assessment many of the on the verses Mr. Baguirov delivers with none real quotation of the particular Persian. But to show the absurdity of Mr. Baguirovs false verse(wherever may be the Persian) is priceless.

Indeed this strong assertion from a Russian scholar of Iranian scientific tests, from the name of Mikhail Kapustin in 1988 (over the time in the event the soviet union was opening nearly the world and there was no tension on scholars to control simple fact) wrote in the Read More Here cultural journal of Soviets: Nizami Ganjavi is one of the finest thinkers and poets of the middle ages and belongs on the Remarkable heritage of Persian literature.

31) The Qom concern can never ever be closed when no less than four hundred 12 months previous manuscripts and some old biographries point out it. Specifically when other outdated biographies also point out it. It might be explained being not likely, but absolutely nothing is complete in this article when discussing the biography of ancient poets. Also unique theories put him or his father as from Qom. In fact Nizami could have been born in Ganja but his father might have effortlessly been from A different town. All We all know is his father was named Yusuf the son of Zaki the son of Mo’ayyad. If we take into consideration this lineage, then most likely his lineage is a local of Ganja, even though Ganja was a house with the Shaddadid Kurds in the time of his Grandfather and so this all over again provides a lot more believability to his other fifty percent getting Kurdish.

one) It's not for the Persian chauvinist, a non-scholar, to find out, as even these kinds of accurate Iranian Students as Prof. Talattof admit how genuinely tainted Iranian scholarship is and was. Right here’s the appropriate estimate from his 2001 ebook: “Adhering way too rigidly to any perspective can be problematic, having said that, as once the editor Pizhman Bakhtiyar gets rid of verses that undermine his interpretation.

The thing is if Einstein wrote a ebook in English, he is really an English writer of Jewish origin. As for Nizami we're 100% of Kurdish mom and I'd even say his father was about 99% likelihood Kurdish (Though he didn't depart us adequate info for making a hundred% absolutely sure). But poet is way more vital than the usual scientist when it comes to identification mainly because a poet expresses cultural Thoughts and so belongs on the culture that he formulated and that nourished him. Nizami's key operate are concerning the Sassanid dynasty and in addition the Irano-Islamic legend of Alexandar (which can be present in huge portions of Shahnameh likewise). So There's a vital cultural component in this article which will not be disregarded and even if Nizamis other 50 percent was Source a Martian, he would still be described as a Persian pory while in the cultural perception. Mainly because Persian was his cultural language and legacy of the tradition he still left guiding. In truth society is a great deal more vital than ethnicity in my view. For example Stalin was a Georgian, but he acted similar to a Russian. Or ataturk was originally Albanian/Macedonian but he grew to become The daddy of Turks.

His Children aren’t adequately aged to receive enrolled in school, and it’s a moot area, he’d probably ship them to A private college or university.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *